Islamic Social Reporting and Financial Distress In List of Sharia Securities

The number of sharia-approved companies in the Indonesia Stock Exchange is growing rapidly. It is important to see how the social performance of these companies, using Islamic Social Reporting Index (ISR Index). Financial Distress as an early sign of a company’s failure is also important to study. This study examines the relation between ISR Index and financial distress in list of sharia securities. The control variables apply in this research are SIZE, ROA, CR, WCTR, DER, and RETA. By using a sample of 129 companies from financial statements and annual reports (2014-2018), three models were built with the Modified Altmans Z-Score, Ohlson O-Score and Zmijewski Zm-Score as a proxy of financial distress. Based on ISR index calculation, the theme of products and services has the highest disclosure score. The lowest disclosure score is corporate governance theme. Panel data regression results show that ISR Index affects financial distress in the Modified Altman’s model. It means the higher the ISR index value, the greater the likelihood of companies run into financial distress. Whereas in Ohlson’s and Zmijewski’s model, ISR Index has no effect on financial distress. Means relationship between ISR Index and Financial Distress (Ohlson’s and Zmijewski’s) is unexplainable by the model.

Research on the prediction of corporate financial distress have been carried out with a variety of explanatory variables and methodological techniques. Started by (Beaver, 1966) using financial ratio with univariate discriminant analysis model to distinguish failing and non-failing companies.
Then, (Altman, 1968) developed Beaver model using financial ratio with multiple discriminant analysis approach to predict a company's failure.
Altman also made adjustments towards Z-Score model which had been built by Z'-Score and Z"-Score models that can be used not only for manufacturing companies (Altman, Iwanicz-Drozdowska, Laitinen, & Suvas, 2017).
Ohlson found that there's limitation in using multiple discriminant analysis in assuming normality and group distribution (Ohlson, 1980). Then Zmijewski with his probit model developed distress prediction using three variables. But the critics toward the static technique of financial distress prediction was also done as continuation of research on financial prediction model (Zmijewski, 1984). Financial distress prediction models which were popularized by Altman, Ohlson, and Zmijewski are traditional models which can be used as early warning signs for financial distress.
Research on financial distress in Indonesia needs to be done seeing that Indonesia Stock Exchange data recorded 21 companies delisting during 2013(OJK, 2019. Delisting can be an indicator that the company's financial performance has decreased. Therefore, it is important to know whether a company is experiencing financial distress or not, as an early warning of company's failure. In other hand, Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) can reduce financial distress better for non-state-owned enterprises compared to stateowned enterprises in China (Shahab, Ntim, & Ullah, 2019). Positive CSR activity significantly decrease company's financial distress. This negative correlation happens in mature companies (Al-Hadi, Chatterjee, Yaftian, Taylor, & Monzur Hasan, 2019).
Based on Sharia Enterprise Theory, in addition to being responsible to stakeholders, a company is also responsible to God by agreeing to His provisions. Based on this theory (Sharia Enterprise Theory), this research uses the concept of Islamic Social Reporting (ISR) as an embodiment of the performance of corporate social responsibility. There are five themes of ISR disclosure index such as finance and investment, product and service, employee, society, and environment (Haniffa, 2002). The theme of good governance was added to complete the previous ISR component (Othman, Thani, & Ghani, 2009a).
Because of the limited research on the correlation between ISR and financial distress, this study analyzed the correlation between ISR and financial distress in Daftar Efek Syariah. The paper is organized as follows.
The next sections reviews some theoretical foundations and literature review. Following it, discuss the research methods employed to analyze the data: sample selection and data collection, research variables, calculation of financial distress, estimation of ISR index, and panel data regression.
The next section presents the empirical result of this study and discussion.
Finally, concluding remarks and limitation of the research as the last section.

LITERATURE REVIEW
Grand Theory used in this study was Agency Theory, Stakeholder Theory, and Legitimacy Theory. This study also used Sharia Enterprise Theory to explain Islamic Social Reporting as a research variable. Theory about financial distress's also explained to establish hypotheses in this study.

Agency Theory
An agency relationship arises when two or more parties where one is appointed as an agent, that is the party acting on behalf of the other party who appoints, namely principals, in a particular area related to the matter of the decision (Ross, 1973). Agency Theory developed by Jensen and Meckling was used to understand the correlation between business principal (shareholder) and agents (company's management party). The agent is the party that manages the company for example managers and the board of directors who act as decision makers in running the company. While the principal is the party that evaluates the information provided by the agent (Jensen & Meckling, 1976).
In agency theory, it is explained that each party has different interest. Where management has an interest in maximizing profits by pursuing projects or short-term investments, shareholders want the maximum welfare for him that can be achieved through projects or long-term investment. One of the ways to overcome this conflict of interest is to monitor the agent through corporate governance (McColgan, 2001).

Stakeholder Theory
Stakeholder is a group or individual that can affect or be affected by an achievement of organizational goals. Stakeholder Theory explained the relation between corporate as an analysis unit with an individual or group that affect or get affected by said business (Freeman, 2010). The implication of this theory form accountability point of view according to Gray et al. is that a company has an obligation to account for (not only financial statements) actions that are the responsibility of the company (Gray, Owen, & Adam, 1996). In line with Gray et al., Van der Laan Smith et al. explained that stakeholder theory is the basis for corporate social disclosure obligations and their application in different companies in various countries (Laan, Adikhari, & Tondkar, 2005).

Legitimacy Theory
Legitimacy Theory is usually used in literature to discuss social and environtment report. Although modestly, it is often used to explain company's social and environmental disclosure policy. Company legitimacy is obtained when there are similarities between the results and what is expected by the society from the company, therefore, there is no demand from society. A company can do social act as a reflection of company's consideration towards society (Deegan, Rankin, & Tobin, 2002). Based on Legitimacy Theory, the company should convince the society that its activities and performance are acceptable to the community. Companies can use their annual reports to illustrate the impression of social and environmental responsibility that has been carried out.

Sharia Enterprise Theory
Sharia Enterprise Theory stated Allah as the center for everything. Human as God's creature has consequence to submit to all of His law (Meutia, 2010).
Based on this theory, economic power is not only on one party, but on many parties, in other words, many stake holders are involved. From sharia enterprise theory's point of view, wealth distribution or value-added does not only apply to the people who are involve directly in a business or to parties who give their contributions to the company, for example: stakeholders, creditor, employee, and government. Other parties who are indirectly involved in the business done by the company, or the parties who don't give any financial or skill contribution should also get the distribution of added value (Triyuwono, 2001).

Islamic Social Reporting and Financial Distress
Sharia enterprise theory principle gives the main form of accountability to God (vertical) which is then translated into the form of accountability (horizontal) to the human race and the natural environment.
The manifestation of horizontal accountability is the existence of addedvalue distribution towards two groups which are the parties who are directly involved with the business (Direct Participants) and the parties who are not directly involved with the business (Indirect Participants). Direct participant consists of: shareholders, management, employees, creditors, suppliers, government. While Indirect Participants consist of: mustahiq (recipients of zakat, infaq, and sadaqah) and the natural environment (for example for nature conservation) (Triyuwono, 2001).

Financial Distress
When a business is experiencing a decline to the point where the company cannot meet financial obligations, the company enters financial distress (Baldwin & Mason, 1983). The first sign of said condition is usually the existence of unpaid debt or dividend reduction. Some companies which experience difficulties went bankrupt while some others recovered and overcame the problem they're facing (Altman, 1968). A company experiencing financial distress which at first only in the form of not able to pay the debt, if it's not solved well the company can go into bankruptcy, liquidation, and even confiscation of assets.
Financial distress categorize into two perspectives based on theoretical analysis and empirical study. From theoretical perspective, financial distress has different degrees. Mild financial distress is in the form of temporary cash flow difficulties, while severe financial distress is business failure or bankruptcy. Whereas from empirical study perspective, financial distress is defined as a situation which is clearly showing the financial difficulty of a company, just like bankruptcy theory based on constitution. The studies on financial distress in the past explored variables which can classify distress into mild, moderate, or bankrupt category. While recent studies consider a single criterion of financial distress (Sun, Li, Huang, & He, 2014).

Islamic Social Reporting and Financial Distress
Bad management is the main determinant factor for financial distress (Gordon, 1970). This bad management is mirrored in how a company tells information to the public. Sharia category companies are also expected to deliver company performance information that also takes into account 162 IQTISHADIA 13,2 responsibilities to Allah SWT, to stakeholders (consumers, employees, and the community), as well as responsibilities to the natural environment. A company with high Islamic social reporting value indicates that the company is well managed. Said company should have less probability to experience financial distress. Based on the theories explained earlier, the hypothesis of this study is that Islamic Social Reporting negatively affect Financial Distress.

Sample Selection and Data Collection
The population in this study includes all companies in List of Sharia Securities in December 2018. The total population is 399 companies. The number of samples is determined by Krejcie and Morgan table for determining sample size from a given population (Krejcie & Morgan, 1970). The number of samples based on the table is 196 companies that was randomly selected. Because this study uses data for 2014-2018, the companies that have been randomly selected then reduced by the companies listed above in 2014, the incomplete data, and suspended companies. So the final sample size is 129 companies.
The type of data applied in this research is secondary data. The research uses financial statements and annual reports published by the company starting in 2014-2018.

Dependent Variable: Financial Distress
Financial distress is the dependent variable in this study. This study uses three financial distress measurement models, namely the Modified Altman Z-Score model (Altman et al., 2017), the Ohlson O-Score model (Ohlson, 1980) and the Zmijewski Zm-Score model (Zmijewski, 1984). The Modified Altman model and the Ohlson model are used because they have a good degree of accuracy in the case of companies in Indonesian capital market (Syamni, Majid, & Siregar, 2018). The Zmijewski model is good for predicting financial distress in emerging markets (Ashraf, G. S. Félix, & Serrasqueiro, 2019). The models are each defined in Appendix I.
Z-Score values are grouped into three categories, namely distress, gray, and health. If the Z-Score is less than 1.1, the company is included in the distress category. If the Z-Score is between 1.1 and 2.6, the company is in the gray category. Meanwhile, the Z-Score is more than 2.6, the company is included in the health category. O-Score values are also grouped into three categories, namely distress, gray, and health. If the O-Score is more Islamic Social Reporting and Financial Distress than 0.38, the company is included in the distress category. If the O-Score is equal to 0.38, the company is in the gray category. Meanwhile, the O-Score is less than 0.38, the company is included in the health category. In other hand, Zm-Score values calculated by the formula above are grouped into two categories, namely distress and health. If the Zm-Score value is more than 0, the company is included in the distress category. If the Zm-Score value is less than 0, the company is included in the health category.

Independent Variable: ISR Index
Islamic Social Reporting Index (ISR Index) is an independent variable in this study. The ISR index was developed to measure the level of ISR of companies listed on the Stock Exchange. There are 43 statement items in 6 themes namely finance and investment, products/services, employees, community, environment (Haniffa, 2002) and corporate governance (Othman et al., 2009a) to estimate ISR Index. The ISR index variable is calculated by the content analysis method (Klaus Krippendorff, 2004) of the company's annual report. Each item gets 1 if there is disclosure in the annual report and gets 0 if there is no disclosure about it. If all items are disclosed in the financial statements, the maximum score is 43.
The relationship between the ISR Index and financial distress is generally expected to be the opposite direction. This means that the higher the ISR index, the lower the financial daistress. However, because of this study using three models that have different characters, the interpretation will be different. In Ohlson and Zmijewski's model, the relationship between ISR and financial distress is in the opposite, means the higher the ISR Index, the lower the O-Score and Zm-Score values. Whereas in the Altman model, the relationship between ISR and Financial Distress is in the same direction.
It means the higher the ISR Index, the higher the Z-Score values.

Control Variable
Control variables used in this research include company size (SIZE), Return on Assets (ROA), Current Ratio (CR), Working Capital Turnover Ratio (WCTR), Debts to Equity Ratio (DER) and Retained Earning to Total Assets (RETA). SIZE is measured by the natural logarithm of Total Assets. Company size is used to control differences in resources, ability to deal with competitors, and opportunities to get funding. Based on previous research, companies that are more likely to have greater ability to overcome financial distress than small companies (Al-Hadi et al., 2019).

13,2
ROA is measured by comparing net income with total assets. CR is measured by comparing current assets to current liabilities. WCTR is measured by comparing revenue with working capital. RETA is measured by comparing retained earnings/retained earnings with total assets. Based on previous research, the four control variables are positively related to financial (Al-Hadi et al., 2019;Imelda & Alodia, 2017;Pranowo, Achsani, Manurung, & Nuryartono, 2010). Whereas DER which is measured by comparing total debt with total equity is negatively related to financial distress (Murni, 2018).

Regression Model
The regression model used in this study is panel data regression with 5 years   (H1) is Random Effect Model. If the Breush-Pagan probability value is less than alpha (0.05) then H0 is rejected, which means the chosen model is REM (Widarjono, 2018).

Variable Description
The results of the research on the financial distress prediction of 129 companies  While the lowest disclosure score is corporate governance theme at 42.8%.

167
Islamic Social Reporting and Financial Distress The descriptive statistical results of this study are in Table 1. Based on Table 1, the highest Z-Score is 119.67 and the lowest is -7.07 and the average is 4.40. The median Z-score is 3.40, which means more companies are included in the health category. Because of the Z-Score limit for the health category is 2.60. The highest and lowest O-Score values are 17.60 and -6.31 with an average of 2.43. indicates that the company has reported sharia social responsibility reporting.

Model Selection in Panel Data
Before estimating the relationship between the financial distress and ISR

Relationship between ISR Index and Financial Distress
The next stage after model selection is the estimation of panel data model.   Zmijewski Zm-Score. While ROA has a probability < 0.05 and a negative coefficient sign, it means that ROA has a negative effect on Financial Distress which is proxied by Zmijewski Zm-Score.

DISCUSSION
The relationship between ISR Index and Financial Distress analyzed using three financial distress models. ISR index negatively affects the Z-Score

Islamic Social Reporting and Financial Distress
The research finding is not suitable with Fich & Slezak research and Gordon's statement which states that poor management, in this case is indicated by the ISR Index value, is a major cause of company failure, which in this study is indicated by financial distress (Fich & Slezak, 2008;Gordon, 1970). Based on Sharia Enterprise Theory, the concept of Islamic Social Reporting (ISR) as an embodiment of the performance of corporate social responsibility. This findings not in line with research by Al-Hadi et al. which states that total corporate social responsibility (CSR) has a positive effect on Z-Score (Al-Hadi et al., 2019).
Based on the regression result, ISR Index has no effect on financial distress in Panel B and C. That means relationship between ISR Index and Financial Distress (proxied by Ohlson O-Score and Zmijewski Zm-Score) is unexplainable. If we assume that Islamic Social Reporting (ISR) as an embodiment of the good corporate governance, this research in line with Pranowo et al. that good corporate governance have no significant impact on corporate financial distress (Pranowo et al., 2010). To the best of author's knowledge, research on the relationship is very limited. Accordingly this model need further testing using other objects.
SIZE as a control variable has no effect on financial distress for all three panels. It means, company size has no impact on financial distress in this research. This contradicts the research of Al-Hadi et al. which states that SIZE has a negative effect on financial distress (Al-Hadi et al., 2019).
ROA affects financial distress for all three panels but has a different mark. In the Altman model ROA has a positive effect on financial distress. CR as a control variable has a positive effect on financial distress in the Altman and Zmijewski models. That means, the more liquid the company is, the smaller the financial distress risk. This research in line with Pranowo et al. that explain CR has a positive effect on financial distress (Pranowo et al., 13,2 2010). While WCTR has a negative effect on financial distress only on Ohlson's model. Its imply that the more efficient the company the smaller the risk of financial distress. This research support Pal opinion (Shrabanti Pal, 2015).
Likewise, DER has an effect on financial distress for all three panels but has a different sign. The Altman DER model has a negative effect on financial distress. Means the higher the debt to equity ratio, the greater the risk of financial distress. Meanwhile the Ohlson and Zmijewski DER models have a positive effect on financial distress. That means, the higher the DER, the greater the financial distress risk. The findings in line with Noviandri research (Noviandri, 2014). Based on the results of the study, RETA has a positive effect on financial distress in the three panels. That means, even though the company has good profitability, it still has the risk of financial distress. Imelda and Alodia's findings in obedience to this research (Imelda & Alodia, 2017). The results showed that the relationship between the ISR Index and financial distress can be explained through the Altman Z-Score Modified model. Because by using the Modified Altman Z-Score as the dependent variable, the ISR Index has a negative effect on financial distress. It means that the higher the value of the ISR Index, the greater the possibility of companies experiencing financial distress. ISR Index has no effect on financial distress in Ohlson and Zmijewski model. That means relationship between ISR Index and Financial Distress (proxied by Ohlson O-Score and Zmijewski Zm-Score) is unexplainable by the model. Accordingly this model need further testing using other objects.

LIMITATION
This study has several weaknesses, first the sample is not differentiated into a healthy company and experiencing financial distress. Second, the ISR Index is calculated as the total items disclosed. The relationship of each theme from the ISR Index to financial distress needs to be done to see in more detail which theme is more influential. Further research on the association between the ISR Index and financial distress also needs to be done considering that there are still gaps in the results of the study. otherwise) -0.521*(NI t -NI t-1 )/ (NI t +NI t-1 )). NI t is Net

Appendix I. Variable Definition and Measurement
Income year t and NI t-1 is Net Income year t-1.